Skip to content

Homeowners insurance in Pennsylvania

Compare carriers, see Pennsylvania minimums, and quote in 60 seconds.

We never sell your information.

A+ BBB Licensed in PA Open 7 days · 9 AM – 7 PM

We shop carriers including

  • Hippo
  • Nationwide
  • Travelers
  • The Hartford
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Safeco
  • Erie Insurance
Statewide

Pennsylvania homeowners insurance

Pennsylvania homeowners insurance is mostly priced on three drivers: dwelling replacement cost, roof age, and ZIP-level claim history. The replacement-cost number is the one most homeowners get wrong — the carrier's auto-fill estimator is conservative, and an under-insured dwelling produces an underpaid claim if the home is a total loss. We use a full replacement-cost estimator on every quote, not the carrier's default. Roof age matters because anything over 20 years risks an actual-cash-value endorsement that hurts at claim time.

Pennsylvania weather risk varies more than people expect. Northwest counties along Lake Erie see lake-effect snow loads that drive ice-dam claims. Susquehanna and Delaware River corridors carry meaningful flood exposure outside the official Special Flood Hazard Areas, which means flood is worth quoting separately even if your mortgage doesn't require it. Wind risk is moderate across most of the state but elevated in the southeast counties during severe-storm season. We size deductibles and named-peril endorsements to match the actual exposure.

Homeowners insurance by Pennsylvania county

Frequently asked questions

How is replacement cost different from market value on a home?

Market value is what you could sell the home for; replacement cost is what it would cost to rebuild it from the foundation up at today's labor and material prices. They're different numbers, sometimes by a lot. Older homes in expensive neighborhoods often have replacement costs higher than market value because of materials and finish costs. Newer suburban homes often go the other way. The replacement-cost number is what your dwelling limit needs to support.

Do I need flood insurance if I'm not in a FEMA flood zone?

Often yes. FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas mark the worst statistical risk, but flood claims happen well outside those zones. Pennsylvania river corridors (Susquehanna, Delaware, Allegheny, Monongahela) and any property near a creek or stream carry real flood risk that homeowners insurance never covers. We quote flood through the National Flood Insurance Program and through several private flood markets.

Will my premium go up if I file a claim?

Usually, yes — though the size and type of claim matter. A small water-damage claim at most carriers triggers a multi-year surcharge. A wind or hail claim often doesn't, because weather claims are catastrophic and not driver-of-the-policyholder. Frequency matters more than severity for surcharge purposes. Two small claims in three years hurts more than one moderate claim.

What about jewelry, firearms, or collectibles?

Standard homeowners policies have sub-limits — typically $1,500 to $5,000 — on jewelry, firearms, fine art, silverware, and similar high-value personal property. If you own items above the sub-limit, schedule them on a personal-articles endorsement or a separate inland marine policy. Scheduled items typically have no deductible and no theft sub-limit at most carriers.

Ready for a Pennsylvania homeowners quote?

We never sell your information.

A+ BBB Trustpilot reviews Licensed in PA Open 7 Days · 9 AM – 7 PM Devon, PA HQ